Is This Considered Cheating? Modern Boundaries Explained
He liked her photo. She texts her ex. They share everything with a coworker. They watch porn. They confide in AI.
What counts as cheating anymore?
The lines between fidelity and betrayal have blurred dramatically in the digital age. Behaviors that didn't exist 20 years ago are now everyday relationship landmines.
This guide will help you understand modern cheating debates, define your own boundaries, and have the crucial conversations with your partner before lines are crossed.
Try a few questions right now
Free · No sign-up
Why Cheating Definitions Vary
According to a 2024 Pew Research study, 73% of couples disagree on at least one behavior that constitutes infidelity.
What almost everyone agrees is cheating:
- Physical sexual contact with someone outside the relationship
- Ongoing romantic relationship with another person
What's heavily debated:
- Emotional intimacy with someone else
- Porn consumption
- Following or liking an ex on social media
- Private messaging with potential romantic interests
- AI companion relationships
- Strip clubs
- Fantasy about others
Why opinions differ:
- Personal history and past trauma
- Cultural and religious background
- Relationship structure agreements
- Generational differences
- Individual attachment styles
The Real Definition of Infidelity
Rather than debating specific acts, relationship expert Dr. Shirley Glass (author of "Not Just Friends") offers a framework:
"Infidelity is any behavior that creates emotional or physical intimacy with someone outside the relationship while simultaneously building walls with your partner."
Key indicators:
- Secrecy - Would you hide this from your partner?
- Emotional investment - Is this taking energy from your relationship?
- Sexual/romantic energy - Is there attraction involved?
- Deception - Are you lying, even by omission?
If the answer to multiple questions is yes, you're likely in infidelity territory—regardless of whether anything "physical" happened.
The Cheating Spectrum: What Research Says
Level 1: Universally Considered Cheating
Physical affairs: Sexual contact with someone else Romantic relationships: "I love you" to another person, ongoing dating
Agreement: 95%+ of couples agree this is cheating
Level 2: Most Consider This Cheating
Emotional affairs: Deep emotional intimacy with someone else Sexting: Explicit messages with someone else Secret dating: Meeting up privately with romantic interest
Agreement: 70-90% consider this cheating
Level 3: Debated Territory
Heavy flirting: In-person or online Private DMs with potential interests: Even without explicit content Maintaining active dating profiles: While in a relationship Secret friendships: Hiding a close friend from your partner
Agreement: 50-70% consider this problematic, though not always "cheating"
Level 4: Highly Personal
Watching pornography: Wide range of opinions Strip clubs or lap dances: Context and consent matter Following/liking attractive people on social media Fantasizing about others Using AI companions for intimate conversations
Agreement: Highly varies—must be discussed individually
Deep Dive: The Most Debated "Cheating" Behaviors
1. Emotional Affairs
What it is: Deep emotional intimacy with someone outside the relationship, often without physical contact.
Warning signs:
- Confiding in them before your partner
- Hiding the depth of the relationship
- Comparing them favorably to your partner
- Looking forward to seeing them more than your partner
- Sexual tension present but not acted on
Why it's harmful: According to research by Dr. Shirley Glass, emotional affairs are often more damaging to relationships than purely physical ones because they involve betrayal of emotional trust.
Questions to ask yourself:
- Do I share things with this person I don't share with my partner?
- Would I behave differently if my partner were watching?
- Am I attracted to this person?
- Am I keeping secrets about this relationship?
2. Pornography Use
The debate:
- Some view it as cheating: Giving sexual energy to images/videos of others
- Some view it as personal: Private activity that doesn't affect the relationship
- Some view it as conditional: Acceptable in moderation, problematic if excessive or secretive
What research says: Mixed findings. Some studies link frequent porn use to decreased relationship satisfaction; others find no connection. Context matters—addiction, secrecy, and comparison to partner are the real concerns.
Key questions for couples:
- Is porn use disclosed or secret?
- Does it affect our intimate life?
- Does it involve content that violates our values?
- Is there addiction or problematic patterns?
3. Ex-Partner Contact
The spectrum:
- Following on social media
- Liking their posts
- Occasional friendly texts
- Regular communication
- Meeting up privately
- Emotional or physical reconnection
Where couples often draw lines:
- Transparency: Does your partner know about contact?
- Frequency: Occasional vs. constant
- Content: Friendly vs. intimate
- Motivation: Genuine friendship vs. keeping options open
Questions to discuss:
- What level of contact with exes is acceptable?
- Must all contact be disclosed?
- What if they reach out first?
- What if we share children with an ex?
4. AI Companions and Chatbots
The new frontier: Apps like Replika and Character.AI allow intimate conversations with AI. Is this a form of cheating?
Arguments that it is:
- Emotional energy directed elsewhere
- May involve "romantic" or "sexual" content
- Creates expectations partner can't meet
- Kept secret from partner
Arguments that it isn't:
- It's not a real person
- May help with social anxiety
- Similar to reading romance novels
- Can be therapeutic
Questions to consider:
- Is this taking something from our relationship?
- Would I be comfortable if my partner knew?
- Is this replacing intimacy with my partner?
5. Flirting
The spectrum:
- Playful compliments (generally acceptable)
- Sexual innuendo (debated)
- Physical flirtation (touch, closeness)
- Explicit come-ons
- Pursuing someone's attention
Where it becomes problematic:
- When it's hidden
- When it's with someone you're attracted to
- When it's ongoing with the same person
- When it would hurt your partner to witness
How to Define Your Boundaries Together
The goal isn't to agree with the "average" opinion. It's to create shared understanding with YOUR partner.
Step 1: Discuss Before Problems Arise
Have this conversation when things are good—not as a response to suspected betrayal.
Step 2: Ask These 20 Questions
Physical boundaries:
- What physical contact with others is acceptable?
- What about dancing at parties?
- Views on massages from others?
- What about gym or sports partners of your attracted gender?
Digital boundaries: 5. Is following exes on social media okay? 6. What about liking attractive people's photos? 7. Are private DMs with others acceptable? 8. What about dating apps—delete or just don't use?
Emotional boundaries: 9. Is having a "work wife/husband" acceptable? 10. How much confiding in others is okay? 11. What about close friendships with your attracted gender? 12. When does a friendship become too close?
Sexual boundaries: 13. Views on pornography? 14. What about strip clubs? 15. Views on AI companions with romantic features? 16. Is fantasy about others acceptable?
Transparency: 17. Must all communication be open to each other? 18. What about passwords and phone access? 19. What must be disclosed? What can be private? 20. How do we handle mistakes or boundary crossings?
Step 3: Create Shared Agreements
Write down what you've agreed to. Not as a contract, but as clarity.
Example agreements:
- "We agree that private romantic messaging is off-limits."
- "We're comfortable with each other having opposite-sex friends, with transparency."
- "Porn is acceptable if it doesn't affect our intimacy."
- "We'll tell each other if someone is flirting with us."
Step 4: Revisit Regularly
Boundaries may evolve as your relationship does. Check in annually.
What to Do If a Boundary Has Been Crossed
If you've discovered (or committed) something that violates your agreement:
If You Crossed a Line:
- Take responsibility - No minimizing or deflecting
- Understand their hurt - Listen to impact, not just intent
- Answer questions honestly - Transparency rebuilds trust
- Commit to change - Actions, not just words
- Seek support - Consider couples therapy
If Your Partner Crossed a Line:
- Process your emotions - It's okay to feel hurt, angry, betrayed
- Get the facts - What actually happened?
- Assess the severity - One-time mistake vs. pattern?
- Communicate your needs - What do you need to move forward?
- Decide your path - Repair together or separate?
The Bottom Line
There is no universal definition of cheating. What matters is:
- You and your partner agree on boundaries
- Those boundaries are clear and specific
- Both partners respect the agreements
- Breaches are addressed honestly
The fact that you're reading this suggests you care about doing relationships right. That's already more than most.
Have the Conversation Tonight
Ready to explore boundaries with your partner?
Try Our Couples Question Cards - Designed to spark the conversations that define and protect your relationship.
Sources
- Glass, S. (2003). Not Just Friends: Rebuilding Trust and Recovering Your Sanity After Infidelity.
- Pew Research Center (2024). Views on Marriage and Cohabitation in the U.S.
- Gottman, J. M. (2011). The Science of Trust.
- Perel, E. (2017). The State of Affairs: Rethinking Infidelity.
- Spring, J. A. (2012). After the Affair: Healing the Pain and Rebuilding Trust.


