Skip to main content
    Christmas Would You Rather: 100 Questions for Kids, Family, Friends & Couples
    Party Games

    Christmas Would You Rather: 100 Questions for Kids, Family, Friends & Couples

    Here We Ask TeamNovember 9, 202610 min read

    Christmas Would You Rather is the easiest holiday game there is: one person reads two options, everyone has to pick one, and the fun is in defending your choice. It needs no setup, works for kids and grandparents at the same table, and fills the gap between dinner and dessert.

    Below are 100 Christmas Would You Rather questions, sorted so you can grab the right list fast: kids, the whole family, funny ones for friends, harder choices for adults, and a set just for couples.

    Try a few questions right now

    Free · No sign-up

    How to play Christmas Would You Rather

    1. One person reads a question out loud. Everyone answers at the same time, by pointing left or right, holding up one or two fingers, or just shouting.
    2. No "neither" and no "both." Picking is the whole game.
    3. Each person gets one sentence to defend their answer. This is where the laughs come from.
    4. The person with the most unexpected answer reads the next question.

    Optional rules for a livelier round: keep score of who sides with the majority most often, play in teams (kids vs. adults is a classic), or let the loser of each round take the last cookie off their plate, not yours.

    What makes a Would You Rather question good

    Would You Rather is one of the most-played formats on Here We Ask. Our couples version is the second most-started deck on the whole site, ahead of every group deck. And when we look at which Would You Rather cards people share, the leader is not the silliest one. It's this:

    "Would you rather hear the truth immediately or gently over time?"

    That says something useful about the game. The funny questions get the laughs, but the ones people pass on are the ones where the answer tells you something about the person. A good round mixes both: start silly, and slip in a few choices that make people think for a second.

    Christmas Would You Rather for kids

    Simple, imaginative and safe for the youngest players.

    1. Would you rather be one of Santa's elves or one of his reindeer?
    2. Would you rather have a snowball fight or build a snowman?
    3. Would you rather eat only candy canes or only gingerbread for a week?
    4. Would you rather have a nose that glows like Rudolph's or ears that jingle like bells?
    5. Would you rather ride in Santa's sleigh or visit the North Pole workshop?
    6. Would you rather open one present every day of December or all of them on Christmas morning?
    7. Would you rather live in a gingerbread house or an igloo?
    8. Would you rather have a pet reindeer or a pet penguin?
    9. Would you rather be able to talk to snowmen or fly with reindeer?
    10. Would you rather decorate the tree or bake the cookies?
    11. Would you rather find a giant present that's empty or a tiny present with something amazing inside?
    12. Would you rather have snow every day of the year or never see snow again?
    13. Would you rather wear an ugly Christmas sweater for a whole week or wear a Santa hat to school every day?
    14. Would you rather be the star on top of the tree or the present underneath it?
    15. Would you rather spend Christmas at the beach or in a snowy cabin?
    16. Would you rather sing a song in front of everyone or tell a joke in front of everyone?
    17. Would you rather have hot chocolate with marshmallows or with whipped cream?
    18. Would you rather meet the Grinch or Frosty the Snowman?
    19. Would you rather help Santa deliver presents or help the elves make them?
    20. Would you rather get a puppy for Christmas or a trip to anywhere you want?
    21. Would you rather have a Christmas tree in your bedroom or a slide down your stairs?
    22. Would you rather sled down the biggest hill in town or ice skate on a frozen lake?
    23. Would you rather leave Santa cookies or carrots for the reindeer?
    24. Would you rather be able to make it snow whenever you want or make it Christmas whenever you want?
    25. Would you rather wake up in the middle of the night and see Santa, or never know whether he was real?

    Christmas Would You Rather for the whole family

    For mixed ages at the dinner table. These spark stories, not just answers.

    1. Would you rather have Christmas dinner at home or at a fancy restaurant?
    2. Would you rather keep every old family tradition or start a brand-new one this year?
    3. Would you rather have a real tree that sheds or a fake tree that never changes?
    4. Would you rather spend Christmas with the whole extended family or just the people in this room?
    5. Would you rather give a homemade gift or a store-bought one?
    6. Would you rather wrap all the presents or cook the whole dinner?
    7. Would you rather watch the same Christmas movie every year or a different one every year?
    8. Would you rather have a white Christmas or a sunny Christmas?
    9. Would you rather open presents on Christmas Eve or Christmas morning?
    10. Would you rather receive one big gift or lots of small ones?
    11. Would you rather go caroling door to door or host a Christmas party?
    12. Would you rather have Christmas music playing all of December or none at all?
    13. Would you rather travel somewhere new for Christmas or stay home in your pajamas?
    14. Would you rather lose the TV remote or lose the leftover pie?
    15. Would you rather do the dishes or take out all the wrapping paper?
    16. Would you rather relive your favorite Christmas or see what Christmas looks like in fifty years?
    17. Would you rather have a family photo in matching pajamas or matching sweaters?
    18. Would you rather know exactly what you're getting or be completely surprised?
    19. Would you rather bake a hundred cookies or eat a hundred cookies?
    20. Would you rather spend Christmas Day outdoors or entirely by the fireplace?

    Funny Christmas Would You Rather for friends and parties

    For Friendsmas, the office party or a secret Santa night.

    1. Would you rather sit next to a toddler or a talkative uncle at Christmas dinner?
    2. Would you rather have "All I Want for Christmas Is You" stuck in your head for a month or never hear it again?
    3. Would you rather wear an ugly sweater to a wedding or a suit to an ugly sweater party?
    4. Would you rather regift a present to the person who gave it to you or get caught regifting by a stranger?
    5. Would you rather have a beard like Santa's or a laugh like Santa's?
    6. Would you rather be the person who forgot the secret Santa gift or the one who spent way over the limit?
    7. Would you rather untangle Christmas lights for an hour or wrap presents with no tape?
    8. Would you rather only eat leftovers until New Year's or skip Christmas dinner entirely?
    9. Would you rather be trapped in a Christmas rom-com or a Christmas action movie?
    10. Would you rather be in charge of the office party or banned from it?
    11. Would you rather have the Grinch's heart or Scrooge's money?
    12. Would you rather get socks every Christmas for the rest of your life or never get a gift again?
    13. Would you rather be the elf on the shelf or the person who has to move it every night?
    14. Would you rather sing karaoke at the party or give a toast?
    15. Would you rather have your group chat read out loud at dinner or your search history?
    16. Would you rather spend Christmas with your ex's family or your boss's family?
    17. Would you rather dress up as a reindeer for a day or as a Christmas tree?
    18. Would you rather be the friend who hosts or the friend who brings the drinks?
    19. Would you rather fall asleep during the movie or during the toast?
    20. Would you rather open your presents in front of everyone or alone where nobody sees your face?

    Christmas Would You Rather: harder choices for adults

    These still sound light, but people tend to explain their answers for a while.

    1. Would you rather have one perfect Christmas Day or a whole relaxed week with nothing planned?
    2. Would you rather spend the holidays with people you love but find exhausting, or people you like but don't know well?
    3. Would you rather give your time or your money to people who need it this Christmas?
    4. Would you rather hear the honest truth about your gift or a kind white lie?
    5. Would you rather relive one Christmas from your childhood or skip ahead to one twenty years from now?
    6. Would you rather keep the peace at dinner or say what you actually think?
    7. Would you rather be the person everyone relies on at Christmas or the person nobody expects anything from?
    8. Would you rather spend Christmas somewhere beautiful but alone or somewhere ordinary with everyone?
    9. Would you rather receive a heartfelt letter or an expensive gift?
    10. Would you rather end the year with a clean slate or with one big unfinished dream?
    11. Would you rather fix one old family argument or start one new family tradition?
    12. Would you rather be remembered for your generosity or your sense of humor?
    13. Would you rather know what everyone really thinks of your cooking or never find out?
    14. Would you rather slow December down or speed it up?
    15. Would you rather be home for every Christmas or somewhere new every Christmas?

    Christmas Would You Rather for couples

    Cozy, a little revealing, and good for a quiet evening on the couch.

    1. Would you rather spend Christmas Eve with family or with just the two of us?
    2. Would you rather get one meaningful gift or plan one trip together?
    3. Would you rather set a strict gift budget or go all in?
    4. Would you rather decorate together in one evening or slowly over a week?
    5. Would you rather alternate families every year or invent our own Christmas?
    6. Would you rather have a cozy night in or a festive night out?
    7. Would you rather write each other a letter or make each other a gift?
    8. Would you rather have Christmas morning breakfast in bed or a long walk outside?
    9. Would you rather open gifts together quietly or with the whole family watching?
    10. Would you rather be surprised or tell each other exactly what we want?
    11. Would you rather start a new tradition this year or keep things exactly as they are?
    12. Would you rather spend the holidays somewhere snowy or somewhere warm?
    13. Would you rather receive a grand gesture or steady little acts of care all month?
    14. Would you rather have one perfect night together or a little quality time every day?
    15. Would you rather plan every detail of the holidays or improvise?
    16. Would you rather protect our evenings or our weekends next year?
    17. Would you rather talk about next year's plans now or after the holidays?
    18. Would you rather have more "me time" or more "we time" this month?
    19. Would you rather hear the truth immediately or gently over time?
    20. Would you rather feel deeply understood or intensely desired?

    The last few come from our couples Would You Rather deck, including its most-shared card. If your partner's answers surprised you, that deck is free to play and keeps going well past Christmas.

    Tips for a better round

    Mix the lists. Three funny questions, then one harder one, keeps energy up without getting silly or heavy.

    Ask "why" every time. The pick is the setup; the explanation is the punchline.

    Read the room. The adult choices and the couples section are for later in the evening. For mixed ages, stay with the kids and family lists.

    Let the kids be the hosts. Children love reading the questions to adults, and grown-ups' answers are often the funniest part.

    Keep it short. Ten to fifteen questions is a perfect round before dessert. Stop while people still want more.

    Play it on one phone

    If you'd rather not scroll through a list, Here We Ask has Would You Rather as a card game you can play on one phone, free and without downloading an app:

    For hundreds more non-seasonal options, see our Would You Rather questions and the couples edition.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is a good Christmas Would You Rather question? A good one has two options that are both tempting or both a little awful, so people actually have to think. "Would you rather open one present every day of December or all of them on Christmas morning?" works because there is no obvious answer and everyone has a reason.

    Is Christmas Would You Rather suitable for kids? Yes. Questions 1 to 25 are written for children, and questions 26 to 45 work for the whole family. Save the friends, adults and couples sections for older players.

    How many people do you need to play? Two is enough, and there is no upper limit. With big groups, answer by raising one or two fingers so everyone can vote at once.

    How do you make Would You Rather more fun? Make everyone defend their answer in one sentence, play kids vs. adults, and mix silly questions with a few harder ones. The follow-up "why?" matters more than the question.

    Can you play Christmas Would You Rather at an office party? Yes, stick to questions 26 to 59 and skip anything about exes, group chats or personal life. They keep the mood light without putting anyone on the spot.


    More holiday conversation ideas: 80 Christmas questions for family, couples and friends and New Year's Eve questions.

    Tags

    christmas would you ratherwould you ratherchristmasholidaysseasonalparty games

    Share this article